48 years after Star Wars movie, the franchise has forgotten what made audiences fall in love with the character in the first place. So many separate elements in the first Star Wars movie, later retitled A New Hope, contributed to the success of George Lucas’ Western, fantasy, and Japanese cinema-inspired space opera. The world-building, Darth Vader’s character design, the narrative, and the core concept of light vs. dark, Jedi vs. Sith, Rebellion vs. Empire, provided audiences with a hopeful, aspirational, and awe-inspiring experience.

A story is nothing without its characters, however. Larger-than-life personalities like Leia Organa, Han Solo, Obi-Wan Kenobi, and most importantly, Luke Skywalker, gave us people to root for. Luke’s development in A New Hope is all about becoming who you were always meant to be; it’s a classic hero’s journey, one that proves that magical abilities and proficiency with a blade aren’t the only things that allow a hero to do some good in the world (or galaxy) – and it feels like Star Wars has forgotten that.

Quick Links

Luke Skywalker Was A Hero Even Without His Jedi Abilities

Luke Skywalker was a hero long before Obi-Wan Kenobi or Yoda taught him how to wield a lightsaber. Luke barely holds a lightsaber in A New Hope, and he only actively accesses the Force at the end when Obi-Wan encourages him. No, we ire Luke in that first all-important film because he decided to rescue Princess Leia and help the Rebellion even without all that extra power.

Despite his sheltered upbringing, Luke involved himself in the galaxy’s turmoil because he knew it was the right thing to do. He wasn’t afraid of a challenge, the darkness, or even the possibility of death. He swooped in because he understood right from wrong, and in the process, his sincerity, his beliefs, and above all, his hope, inspired others to follow him into battle, too. Would Han Solo have ed the Rebellion without meeting and befriending Luke? I don’t think so.

Star Wars stories like Rogue One: A Star Wars Story and Andor are widely beloved, I believe, for the same reason. Much like Luke in A New Hope, the characters in these Rebellion-era narratives fight against the galaxy’s oppression simply because it’s the right thing to do. They don’t have Jedi powers either, but they still sacrifice a part of themselves to make a difference. It’s relatable and inspiring. Luke’s character, however, has since been mythologized to the point of no return.

Luke Didn't Need The Fame Of The Skywalker Legacy To Be A Hero

Luke and Leia hugging in the center with Anakin Skywalker in Revenge of the Sith to the left and Pe Amidala in Attack of the Clones to the right
Custom Image by Simone Ashmoore

Characters in long-running stories and franchises inevitably grow and change – it’s what makes a story worth following. However, since the events of Return of the Jedi, Luke Skywalker has become a kind of prophet, a being of mystical and unimaginable power. This has, in my opinion, pushed him too far away from what audiences loved about him in A New Hope and even The Empire Strikes Back.

Back then, we didn’t understand the significance of the Skywalker name, or the family’s legacy and impact on the galaxy’s wider history. Darth Vader being Luke and Leia’s father was a brilliant twist. It worked because we didn’t know Anakin Skywalker’s true story yet.

Luke is still undeniably a hero, but he’s now practically untouchable, a Jedi with nearly God-like powers. He represents hope for the entire galaxy, not just the Rebellion.

Now, though, we know about the “Chosen One” prophecy, we know about the tragedy of Anakin’s life and his doomed relationship with Pé Amidala, we know about how intricately Vader was intertwined with Palpatine’s nefarious, power-grabbing schemes, and we know just how special and powerful Luke is supposed to be. Luke is still undeniably a hero, but he’s now practically untouchable, a Jedi with nearly God-like powers. He represents hope for the entire galaxy, not just the Rebellion. That makes him a lot less relatable.

Star Wars Has To Get Back To The Core Of Luke Skywalker's Character

In his appearances in The Mandalorian and The Book of Boba Fett, Luke Skywalker can do no wrong. He easily blasts his way through countless battle droids and saves Grogu and his friends from certain death; Ahsoka Tano sees the best sides of her old Master in Luke, and he’s working to bring back the Jedi, a noble – if somewhat misguided – goal. Characters in Star Wars and the audience are forced to see Luke as a symbol, not a person.

Say what you will about Rian Johnson’s arc for Luke in Star Wars: The Last Jedi, but, for a moment, at least, the story ed that Luke is human. He’s fallible, he makes mistakes, but in the end, he’ll still do what’s right and even die for it. I understand why that story was so divisive, but it gave us one last glimpse of who Luke used to be before his ultimate sacrifice.

Luke Skywalker in The Force Awakens to the left and Luke holding his lightsaber in The Last Jedi to the right
Related
The 8 Biggest Luke Skywalker Sequel Trilogy Complaints: Which Ones Are Right, & Do They All Even Make Sense?

Luke Skywalker's story in the Star Wars sequel trilogy continues to be extremely controversial in the franchise, but was it really all that bad?

1

Luke is a hero not because he’s a Jedi, not because he’s proficient with a lightsaber, or because he can Force-project himself halfway across the galaxy. He’s a hero because his limits never stopped him from fighting for the light. Becoming a Jedi and being the only Jedi understandably changed Luke Skywalker and how he moved through Star Wars’ storytelling, but sometimes, I miss the simple heroic farm boy he used to be.

Star Wars Movies

Release Date

The Mandalorian and Grogu

May 22, 2026

Star Wars: Starfighter

May 28, 2027