I’m still devastated that the legendary DC films. However, despite his enthusiasm and apparent suitability for the roles, Williams was ultimately ed over.
Robin Williams had been lobbying for a superhero role for years, and Batman was at the top of his wish list. He was a longtime fan of the character and frequently expressed interest in playing a Gotham City villain in the DCU timeline. Throughout his career, he demonstrated the kind of range that could bring both menace and humor to a supervillain role. However, Hollywood’s complex casting politics repeatedly left him on the sidelines.
Robin Williams Would Have Made Perfect Sense As A Batman Villain Casting
Robin Williams had a larger-than-life presence that would have been perfect for a Batman villain. Many of his comedic roles, such as those in Aladdin and Mrs. Doubtfire, showcased his ability to shift between manic energy and deep sincerity in a heartbeat. Meanwhile, his dramatic turns in One Hour Photo and Insomnia proved he could be truly terrifying when he wanted to be.
10 Perfect Superhero Actors Who Didn’t Believe They’d Get The Role
Even some of the very greatest superhero stars genuinely thought they had lost the role before delivering critically acclaimed performances.
The best Batman villains tend to balance theatricality with an undercurrent of darkness, and Williams could have embodied that balance effortlessly. His rapid-fire delivery and ability to slip into different personas would have made him a particularly compelling villain, with his knack for unsettling performances adding a sinister undercurrent. His unique mix of warmth and chaos would have made any interpretation of a Batman villain unforgettable.
Robin Williams Came Close To 2 Major Batman Movie Villain Roles
Williams was not just a fan-favorite suggestion for Batman villains – he was actively considered for two major roles. In the late 1980s, Tim Burton’s Batman (1989) was searching for its Joker, and Williams was one of the actors Warner Bros. pursued. However, it turned out he was being used as leverage to pressure Jack Nicholson into g on. When Nicholson finally agreed, Williams was unceremoniously dropped from consideration (via Scraps from the Loft).
10 Missed DC Castings That Could Have Changed Everything
Some truly iconic stars came tantalizingly close to portraying classic DC characters. If they had, they would have changed the whole franchise.
Years later, Williams was once again in the running – this time for The Riddler in Batman Forever (1995). Given his natural inclination for zany, high-energy performances, he seemed like a perfect fit. However, Warner Bros. ultimately chose Jim Carrey, likely due to his rising stardom at the time. Once again, Williams was left disappointed, denied the chance to bring his own spin to Gotham’s rogues' gallery (via Far Out Magazine). Reflecting on this process, Williams commented:
“The Batman films have screwed me twice before. Years ago they offered me The Joker and then gave it to Jack Nicholson, then they offered me The Riddler and gave it to Jim Carrey. I’d be like, ‘Okay, is this a real offer? If it is, then the answer is yes. Don’t pump me again, motherfuckers.'”
Williams’ near-miss with these roles remains one of the biggest "what ifs" in superhero movie history. His ability to blend humor with darkness would have made him an unforgettable Batman villain. Yet, Hollywood politics and timing never aligned in his favor.
Source: Scraps from the Loft & Far Out Magazine
- Created by
- Bob Kane, Bill Finger
- First Film
- Batman
- Latest Film
- The Batman
- Films
- The Batman Part II
- First TV Show
- Batman (1966)
