It's a good episode but not my favorite. Arena is my favorite. As for Kirks love interest The episode where he loved the android woman and died and Spock said "forget" should be considered a good one or him aa a supposed god in the native American woman as his wife. Those episodes never seem to be considered.

I am satisfied with the list.

My favorite film is number 1 and my 2 favorite episodes Arena my number 1

and The Doomsday Machine my number 2.

I can watch Star Trek over and over and never get tired of it. It's such a great show and film franchise. Kirk is my favorite captain of any that came before or after him. In the words of Spock "live long and prosper"

It's too bad she wasn't utilized for the show as a Supergirl in this alternate universe. This edit alternate version was nice to see. Had the series continued maybe they might have included her to help Superman take on Darkseid in a 2 part series ending season which I think would have been special to see along with his sons.

It was a good show. Unfortunately because it wasn't renewed the ending was the best thing they could come up with. Who knows how many more stories could have been made and if this ending would happen a couple of years from now.

It would be insulting if she didn't return. The question is what kind of story can they do? Would she have a cameo if no actual story revolved around her? Would she be an old lady as Susan or digitize her to make her look young? So many questions about a possible return. Do it soon with her.

I have enjoyed watching the series and his appearance in the Arrowverse prior to the initial show title. The films definitely rushed everything. It's too bad the series is going to be over. Once the series is over there's not a single show in CW network that is of any interest to me. These shows look dull and boring. Thanks CW for taking away superhero shows. With both sons now having powers who knows what other stories we could have had for a season 5.

I watching it when it was on and years ago I bought the DVD set at Big Lots. It was good for it's time and some episodes are really good stories. Definitely worth a watch for someone who never saw it before.

I don't know how they are going to pull this off. She's confirmed dead if I . How is the 15th incarnation going to visit her? Unless he's traveling backwards in time this will really complicate things. I don't think it is a good idea to bring her back.