Summary

• Killing off a main character in Honor Among Thieves 2 can set up a hilarious Dungeons & Dragons joke.
• The storytelling potential of having actors come back as new characters allows for higher stakes.
• Retaining actors while killing characters can create a unique and long-lasting franchise.

Killing off a major character could allow Honor Among Thieves 2 updates have been few and far between, despite the fact that the film has become a success both during and after its theatrical run. The storyline, characterization, and homages to the lore of the original tabletop game allow the story to engage its audiences easily. That final draw point also creates ample storytelling opportunities for the sequel to use, harkening to something avid players take advantage of in this system.

Honor Among Thieves 2's potential storywise is both open and clear, as the threat of Thay and the Red Wizards still lingers. Conversely, new adventures could easily emerge to delay the party from that ultimate battle, keeping the sense of openness Dungeons & Dragons' game format possesses. No matter which direction the film takes, one particularly hilarious gag would be a great opportunity for Honor Among Thieves 2, not only as a homage but as a way of progressing the narrative.

Honor Among Thieves 2 Needs To Kill Off A Main Character For A Hilarious D&D Joke

Having The Actor Return As A New Character Would Mirror D&D's Game Style

Honor Among Thieves 2 needs to kill off a main character, as it would allow them to create a hilarious situational D&D joke. Honor Among Thieves' characters already faced death, as Holga Kilgore (Michelle Rodriguez) almost died before she was resurrected. While that moment was played seriously, there is no reason that the sequel could not have another major character death moment that leans further into the source material. In the original game, after a character dies, a player can easily just make a new character and continue in the same story, with no one being the wiser.

Therefore, a main character dying and the actor returning as a brand-new character would be great comedically, no matter how the other characters react. If the other characters ask about the shift, it would create multiple fun misunderstandings, as the new character could be a completely different class with a new arsenal. On the other hand, not acknowledging it at all would be a great source of dramatic irony for audiences. Not only that, but killing off a character could easily raise Honor Among Thieves 2's stakes as new villains emerge.

Killing Off A Lead Will Give Honor Among Thieves 2 Higher Stakes

Honor Among Thieves 2's Villian Could Show Their Might Through Killing A Lead

By killing off a lead character, Honor Among Thieves 2 could raise the stakes as the villain showcases their power, forcing the characters to grow and shift their strategies from the first film. During the course of the original story, the party is forced to both learn the rhythms of its new and get reacquainted with their original group's styles. Their learning curve allowed audiences to see what the party could do and build toward a strong conclusion. That being said, the same strategy cannot work a second time if Honor Among Thieves 2 wants to raise the stakes.

Though the actor could return, the character is gone, creating an emotional toll upon the surviving as they integrate the new character.

Honor Among Thieves 2's possible villains, through killing a major character, could demonstrate how the party must evolve in order to win organically. Though the actor could return, the character is gone, creating an emotional toll on the surviving as they integrate the new person. Great character moments and stake-building could result from this, as it does in an authentic D&D game, especially as alternatives would not truly create the same emotional beats. This choice, alongside raising the stakes, could also ensure franchise longevity as the film can keep its cast and easily kill its characters.

Dungeons & Dragons Lore Means The Franchise Can Kill Characters AND Keep Its Cast

Killing The Character And Keeping The Actor Can Grow Beyond A Gag

Through the original lore, Honor Among Thieves 2 has a rare opportunity that can allow them to kill characters and retain the actors, creating a unique and strong franchise. Honor Among Thieves changes many D&D rules, such as the way sending stones work, for the sake of story and character progression. However, keeping to this base lore and mechanics would allow the franchise to keep its tight group of actors while also letting them dive into new characters and relationships.

Before filming, the cast of Honor Among Thieves played a Dungeons & Dragons one-shot as their characters.

Many major franchises are forced to allow actors to leave and once a character dies or arrives. Since D&D allows players to just keep coming back, the actors can remain and simply explore new facets of the world that are needed for the narrative to progress. This would allow Honor Among Thieves 2 to become a unique property as actors can take on new characters and relationships, much like many D&D players do. Through this, audiences get another great homage, and a fascinating storytelling space is born, showcasing what happens when a character's death is not truly the end.