Although on Paramount+ so far and there has been no confirmation of a second season, if the fan reaction is any indication of the show's potential longevity, then it seems like another installation into the All Stars format is a near guarantee.
Fans of return to the series for years back, and All Stars finally made those dreams come true. But of course, there are some players that fans are already hoping will make an appearance on a second season too.
Jodi Weatherton
Jodi Weatherton is one of those Challenge players that fans always wanted and expected more appearances from.
She was an incredibly physically dominant player who really didn't have to play politics in order to win, but when she seemed to be at her competitive peak, she just stopped showing up on the series. The creation of All Stars provides the perfect opportunity for Jodi to return and show everyone what she's got now.
Rachel Robinson
Although the game has changed a bit since Rachel Robinson last appeared, when she was a regular on The Challenge she could give most of the male competitors a run for their money when it came to the physical competition.
And despite the fact that political gameplay was frowned upon in her era, Rachel showed a natural knack for playing the game from a variety of different angles.
Veronica Portillo
It hasn't been very long since Veronica Portillo last appeared on a season of The Challenge, and while she actually proved that she can for the most part still hang with the new crop of players, it'd be more interesting to see her compete against her contemporaries.
She's always been a masterful social player, so playing with or against people she's familiar with would undoubtedly be entertaining.
Evelyn Smith
The competitive aspect of The Challenge has only gotten more extreme as time has gone on, and although Evelyn started in an era where it wasn't as hard of a game, it seems likely that she'd still be as insanely dominant as she was in her original run on the show.
She was really a game-changer when it came to the athleticism of the women on the series, so fans are understandably desperate for her to return.
Paula Meronek
More affectionately known as Paula Walnuts, Paula was a player who didn't have luck on her side for the majority of her early Challenge career, but she ultimately wound up becoming a pretty dominant player.
On top of that, she really got into a lot of the drama that occurred on the show, and she had strong relationships with many other competitors, so that alone would make her an interesting addition to All Stars.
Casey Cooper
Casey Cooper was never a player who seemed in it to really play the game, but that is a huge reason why she is still so popular with the audience.
Although All Stars is a much tougher game than some of the contestants may have expected, it still feels more lighthearted and fun than the mainstream series, so adding someone as goofy as Casey would really change the dynamic of the game in a great way.
Katie Doyle
Katie has already come back to The Challenge for the first season of All Stars, and fans were thrilled to realize that despite the years that have gone by, she's still the same old feisty, hilarious Katie.
While watching her faceplant into the water again is painful, hearing her swear like a sailor on Paramount+ is hilarious, and there's no reason why she shouldn't return again for a second season of the show.
Beth Stolarczyk
Beth was truly the original Challenge villainess, she was the pot-stirrer and drama-starter before it was cool, and she loved it. Ironically, while her playing style made her the outcast among the players of her era, she'd fit right in with the reality-savvy stars of the current Challenge.
As far as entertainment value goes, it's hard to find anyone better, and she deserves to be on the second season of All Stars.
Tina Barta
Tina Barta is best ed as the super-sassy girl who was never afraid to speak her mind, and she has exactly the kind of personality that makes reality TV gold.
All Stars is the opportunity for The Challenge to get back to its messier, more fun, and more dramatic roots, and adding someone like Tina into the second season of the series would only add to that.
Coral Smith
Many female competitors throughout The Challenge's history have made a huge impression on audiences, but there are few characters who were more memorable and unique than Coral Smith.
While she wasn't as physically dominant as some of the other players, her confessionals were always some of the best in the season, and she was never the type to back down from any confrontation. It comes as no surprise that most fans would love to see her on an All Stars season.
