Biniyam’s ex-wife left him for the same reason.

When Natalie said that Biniyam was messaging him after leaving the retreat, it sounded believable, but Biniyam is setting the record straight.

Biniyam posted a clip showing Natalie claiming that Biniyam slid into her DMs and proceeded to share a screen recording of the chats between them to prove she was lying. “The screenshots provided below are a response to recent accusations against me 'sliding' into a cast member's DM's upon my departure from the show,” Biniyam wrote in his caption. “The accusations, as you can see, are false,” he added. Biniyam insisted that he’s only tried to maintain healthy friendships with cast and that he is currently working on “self-improvement.”

“Do not appreciate these false accusations against me.”

Biniyam wished to be a better father to his son and didn’t appreciate the slander. He hoped that others could do the same and move forward with their lives in a positive way like he has. The screenshots showed that Biniyam had sent Natalie his first message back in May 2021 when he shared a link to his “Dancey Dancey” music video telling her he and Ariela were her fans and asking for a repost. Natalie never responded to him then and even left his December 2021 message unread. In April 2024, Biniyam asked Natalie, “How are you my friend?”

What Biniyam Slamming Natalie For Her Lies Means For Her Reputation

Why Is Natalie Targeting Biniyam?

Natalie’s first ever message on Instagram to Biniyam was her wanting to know if Josh was talking to Biniyam behind her back. There were no flirty messages exchanged between Natalie and Biniyam apart from them tagging each other in promotional videos of 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2. The last set of messages showed them wishing each other Merry Christmas. Natalie made the shocking claims about Biniyam on Between The Sheets, which was supposedly filmed in October 2024. As per Natalie, Biniyam was trying to test the waters to see if she was single.

Biniyam’s screenshots prove that Natalie was making up tall stories about what Biniyam said to her in her DMs. It was Natalie who had tried to get Biniyam to spill about his interactions with Josh while filming the show. Biniyam has shown no interest in dating Natalie through his DMs to her. Interestingly, Ariela had the s to Biniyam’s social media all along, so it’s not like he would have tried to flirt with a 90 Day Fiancé co-star on Instagram. Besides, the statement posted by Biniyam also sounds like something Ariela did on his behalf.

Our Take On Biniyam Claiming Natalie Lied About DMs

Did Natalie Want Biniyam To Play Along?

Ariela recently itted that she and Biniyam used 90 Day Fiancé to give him a platform to showcase his talents. Ariela is still working as Biniyam’s manager. There’s a chance that Biniyam and Ariela never got divorced but are back together as a couple after 90 Day: The Last Resort. Still, Biniyam’s receipts show that he never took an interest in Natalie. She may have mistaken his kindness for flirtation or perhaps wanted a storyline like Sophie Sierra, who was getting DMs from a cast member, as her own storyline for her next spin-off.

90 Day: The Last Resort airs Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on TLC.

Source: Biniyam Shibre/Instagram